As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Picks are based on manufacturer specs, independent reviews and owner reports.
Quick verdict
Choose the Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) if you want ductile iron construction resists cracking under heavy impact far better than cast iron. Choose the Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise if you'd rather have built-in anvil surface adds a striking area for light metalwork tasks. Overall we rank the Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Bench Vise 2026 list.
Winner overall: Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R)
Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) vs Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise compared
Every difference that matters, in one table.
Keep researching
- Best Bench Vise 2026
- Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) review
- Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise review
- All woodworking
Bottom line
Choose the Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) if you want ductile iron construction resists cracking under heavy impact far better than cast iron. Choose the Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise if you'd rather have built-in anvil surface adds a striking area for light metalwork tasks. Overall we rank the Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Bench Vise 2026 list.
Best OverallWilton
Ductile iron construction resists cracking under heavy impact far better than cast iron
- 6.5-inch jaw width
- Swivel base
- Ductile iron base, cast iron body
- Pipe jaws included
✓ Pros
- Built-in anvil surface adds a striking area for light metalwork tasks
- Swivel base at a fraction of premium vise pricing
- Solid cast iron holds up to years of general shop use
✕ Cons
- Smaller jaw width limits capacity on larger stock
- Swivel lock can loosen over time and needs occasional retightening
Best ValueYost
Built-in anvil surface adds a striking area for light metalwork tasks
- 4.5-inch jaw width
- Swivel base
- Cast iron body
- Anvil surface
✓ Pros
- Built-in anvil surface adds a striking area for light metalwork tasks
- Swivel base at a fraction of premium vise pricing
- Solid cast iron holds up to years of general shop use
✕ Cons
- Smaller jaw width limits capacity on larger stock
- Swivel lock can loosen over time and needs occasional retightening
FAQ
Common questions
Which is better, the Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) or the Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise?
Choose the Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) if you want ductile iron construction resists cracking under heavy impact far better than cast iron. Choose the Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise if you'd rather have built-in anvil surface adds a striking area for light metalwork tasks. Overall we rank the Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) higher: #1 versus #2 in our Best Bench Vise 2026 list.
What is the difference between the Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) and the Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise?
The Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) stands out because ductile iron construction resists cracking under heavy impact far better than cast iron, while the Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise stands out because built-in anvil surface adds a striking area for light metalwork tasks. The trade-offs differ too: the Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R)'s ma in caveat is that heavy, needs a solidly built bench section to mount, and the Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise's is that smaller jaw width limits capacity on larger stock.
Is the Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) worth it over the Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise?
For most buyers, yes: it's our #1 pick. Consider the Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise instead if heavy, needs a solidly built bench section to mount is a deal-breaker for you.
Who should buy the Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise instead of the Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R)?
The Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise suits value-focused buyers who want the most for their money, while the Wilton 28822 Reversible Bench Vise (Model 4650R) is best for buyers who want the best overall package.
Keep researching
Related guides & comparisons
Yost Vises 445 Combination Vise
